Use our rumours form to send us nhl trade rumors.



21 Sep 2021 14:20:59
Blues offer for rielly

STL- Scandella 1st 2023 Sanford
for
TOR - reilly

lhd replacement on cheap, big bodied 2/ 3lw who can score and play the physical game that tor needs. 1st in good draft.

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Sep 2021 15:11:14
Replace Sanford with Thomas since after this deal you can’t afford him anyways.

21 Sep 2021 15:34:39
Tor: Reilly 1.5 retain
Stl: Thomas bortuzzo 1st 2022.

21 Sep 2021 16:52:51
Sanford has never been more than a 3-4LW for the Blues. That said, unless he has a breakout season he shouldn't cost much more if at all than what he currently makes. Scandella is solid. The 1st is not reliant on a re-sign, cap is about even, so Yea, I would do this.
Good prop Colt.

21 Sep 2021 19:05:48
Thomas will never be apart of a rental pending ufa trade. The fact that leafs and randy ask is laughable at best. The 1st. A solid dman in return signed for a few years on great aav with sanford a 2/ 3 lw who makes 2 mil now and is not going to need much more with a first in a great draft. That is by far a great proposal.

i am glad soomeone thinks so on the leafs.

21 Sep 2021 19:08:40
leafs1994

Thomas by himself would cost more then reilly so you prop is a joke.

21 Sep 2021 22:25:46
Pretty good prop Hotwing. I like this one.

22 Sep 2021 12:53:14
Lol ok him and his 12 points last year is elite.

22 Sep 2021 13:24:37
Faulk brought back
Edmondson (27yr unsigned) Bokk (same year 1st rd) and a 1st

So rielly brings back
Bortuzzo (32yr 1yr) bolduc (same year 1st rd) and 1st rd pick bare minimum

Edmondson was younger than bortuzzo is so blues might need to add another prospect or pick

Anything less and just leave Colt.

22 Sep 2021 14:03:30
Let's look at the value

Scandella > borts
Sanford > bolduc
1st

I am sorry ypu want pieces unavailable but that's the offer and looks like several others like it. Also the cap doesn't work in your trade lol.

22 Sep 2021 16:48:19
The Faulk deal seems to have some facts wrong as I remember thinking at the time how little it took to get him since he immediately signed a 6 year deal (which had to be in place pre-trade) . Edmundson was also on an expiring contract like Faulk. Edmundson then signed in free agency to Mtl at end of season. Canes got only 1 season from him.

The deal was

To Stl
Faulk (pending UFA) and a 5th
To
Car
Edmundson (pending UFA), Bokk (recent 25th overall pick) and a 7th round pick.

Rielly for Scandella (signed for 3 more seasons), Sanford (pending UFA) and a 1st (may be better than 25th or similar) is worth more than what the Canes got for Faulk IMO. Faulk had to already agree to a contract ahead of time for them to even get that and the Canes swapped out a 5th for a 7th.

With no sign and trade in place, this is fair for Rielly and better than what Faulk returned.

22 Sep 2021 17:24:57
Thanks for clarifying that for us. Also to clarify the 1st would be 2023 not this years.

22 Sep 2021 19:04:59
I don't agree with you often, but this seems like a good deal for both teams. Maybe now that you are in Seattle and they gave you the big bucks, there is less allegiance to the Blues. lol
Blues get an elite top 4 for at least one season. Leafs get 3 cost controlled vet D for the next 3 seasons (Brodie, Muzzin, Scandella) . They can decide to put money into either Sanford or Mikheyev end of season and we are weaker on the LW (or both if price is right) . The 1st in 2023 is not dependent on a re-sign, so assuming the Blues don't regress, should be in the 20's. Leafs don't lose Rielly for nothing and get two players for what he costs now cap wise.

Both teams benefit in the end. I give credit where it is due.

22 Sep 2021 20:08:36
To clarify, I meant the Blues top 4 as a group will be elite.

23 Sep 2021 20:59:27
The beauty thing about the Faulk trade was the hurricanes weren’t trapped with extra years of Edmondson and got a solid at the time prospect in Bokk.

Carolina got to test Edmondson out and when they went a different direction got a pick for him.

So same applies here. I assume Toronto will want to grab a nhl level dman with only 1 year left on him. They then can test him out. If he works they resign him if not they move on and might get a pick for him. Add in a recent 1st rounder by the blues and I can’t see why not the leafs might think about it.

Scandella and his extra years isn’t what I believe the leafs want especially at his price and age.

Not leafs fault if this trade isn’t cap compliant for the blues and it isn’t mine either. You suggested this trade so I’m Just stating what it might take for blues to get leafs to trade rielly.

Another nhl forward isn't but a forward prospect would be

Quite simple really even a non hockey fan can see how this logic works.

23 Sep 2021 23:45:45
You asked for bortuzzo 1st and bolduc. That's just not happening for a rental. You prop is a joke. Faulk cost book and edmundson and came with an extension so if you expect the trade you proposed then rielly better have an extension 6 ×7.

24 Sep 2021 08:38:17
Yeah I changed my proposal colt so the jokes on you

Bortuzzo Bolduc
For
Rielly

If rielly extended blues add 2nd as rielly is much better than Faulk.

24 Sep 2021 13:23:36
Blues are not trading bolduc for an expiring contract he is a center prospect and that is a need for blues. The offer i made is the only offer you get end of story. LOL no gm is going to give this for a rental they most likely won't be able to extend. You say that but faulk had a great season and actually plays defense. yes morgan got more points but his defensive numbers are lacking. Faulk only got bokk and he was not as highly regarded as bolduc. lol.

24 Sep 2021 13:25:26
final offer

Scandella 1st 2024 Zach Sanford.
for
Morgan rielly and Liljgren.

24 Sep 2021 14:34:51
You said same about Bokk until blues added Bokk. U insisted blues stent dealing Bokk to land an dman.

Look what happened 1 week after u insisted Bokk is untouchable.

24 Sep 2021 16:17:14
I never said that. Please shoe me where I said that. you can't cause I never didn't bokk wasn't a highly regarded prospect. At the time kyroy kostin perunovich were our top prospects and guess what you ain't getting kyrou kostin perunovich bolduc kessel galloway roberston for reilly and expiring contract.

In all honesty I could see the Blues offering a 1st for hampus lindolhm and calling it a day.

24 Sep 2021 16:31:38
U tell better stories than Walt Disney.

24 Sep 2021 18:10:50
ok blues say you can lose rielly for nothing. I honestly rather have a more defensive player in Lindholm. he will be cheaper.

25 Sep 2021 22:18:47
Finally it’s over.







 

 

 
Log In or Register to post

User
Pass
Remember me

Forgot Pass