07 Feb 2026 14:47:00
Let’s try this younger retool/ rebuild scenario:

To Tor: Sennecke, Colangelo, Luneau, 2026 1st rd pick, 3rd rd pick 2027

To ANH: Nylander, OEL

2)
To Tor: Guenther, McBain, Tij Iginla, 2026 2 - 2nd rd picks, 2026 3rd rd pick

To Utah: Matthews

To Tor: Isaac Howard, Podkolzin, 2026 2nd rd pick

To Edm: Woll, Maccelli (50% retained ), Domi

To Tor: Soderblom, 2026 2nd rd pick

To Det: Reilly

Next years starting lineup:

Knies JT Sennecke
Guenther Laughton McMann
Iginla McBain Robertson
Soderblom Roy Howard/ Colangelo/ Podkolzin

McCabe Tanev
Luneau Danford
Rifai Carlo
Stetcher/ Benoit

Stolarz/ Hildeby —3rd - AA
Squired picks:1sts:1, 2nds: 4, 3rds: 2.
Now this is a rebuild/ retool.

1.) 07 Feb 2026
07 Feb 2026 15:51:21
Maybe a bit too many forwards as I never even mentioned Cowan, Lorentz or Joshua.

2.) 07 Feb 2026
07 Feb 2026 16:08:02
Sam Colangelo and Tristan Luneau the next great ones or something?

3.) 07 Feb 2026
07 Feb 2026 16:21:02
They would be solid pick ups, but Sennecke is the real key to the deal.

4.) 07 Feb 2026
07 Feb 2026 18:03:18
Matthews and Nylander aren’t being traded. Just stop.

5.) 08 Feb 2026
08 Feb 2026 16:35:02
How do we trade our 2 best players and not #one D or centre in return?
More bad asset management.

6.) 09 Feb 2026
09 Feb 2026 03:45:06
Can’t trade Matthews unless a center is coming back in the deal.
Otherwise trading Matthews leaves the team with only Tavares, Roy and Laughton at center.
At the very least McTavish would have to be one of the players in the Ducks package.

7.) 11 Feb 2026
10 Feb 2026 23:59:05
@CKPS1876 You do realize this site is more wishful thinking and a tossing of potential trade ideas right? If those two big names were to be traded at some point (And who is to say it could not happen? No-one thought the Rantanen deal that came out of nowhere was going to happen let alone him getting dealt 2 times in the same season. ) I think Clarky17 was pretty accurate on the return rate for both of those players although I think the Matthews deal would involve a extra leaf player in the mix. No offense Clarky but I would add the player and then swap out the 2 2rd round picks in 2026 for a 1st instead in 2027. Good Post though.

8.) 12 Feb 2026
12 Feb 2026 09:23:46
@ Clarky and Stryker10 First off great target in Sennecke, he is the PERFECT piece but, how bout getting a bit more of a need back as well. AM34 goes to the Ducks for Sennecke, R McQueen and Solberg. McQueen is a Centre and Solberg is a LD I think. That gets us a future cornerstone player with Knies in McQueen and a future top pairing Defencmen in Stien Solberg. Even if we had to add a little sum sum to get the Ducks to bite on this I’d do it. Sets us up nicely moving forward. Why the Ducks do it? Cause they could use a number 1 Centre for their playoff run this year and next. Then They can decide if Matthews is a guy they wanna move forward with.