29 Jan 2025 03:53:07
JT Miller 31 - Morgan Reilly 30
Miller NTC - Reilly NTC
Miller $8 - Reilly $7.5
Miller goes to a contender - Reilly goes home to Vancouver.
Both players having down years.
To Leafs: JT Miller
To Canucks: Reilly, Minten OR a 2025 - 2nd round pick (Vancouver's choice), Grebenkin
29 Jan 2025 11:20:45
All for it, except, the leafs cannot move Reilly without getting another defenceman back at the same time, if not beforehand.
29 Jan 2025 12:40:39
CKPS. Like who? Who are the Leafs getting before hand and what is the cost to get him?
29 Jan 2025 22:10:09
You gonna run with a D core of OEL, Mcabe, Tanev, Myers, Timmons and Benoit? Lmao…. Good luck.
29 Jan 2025 23:52:17
Lmao? Lol. You never answered the question because you don't have an answer to what you keep stating. Nice try at deflecting though. Your response is the true humour.
30 Jan 2025 02:12:21
Ckps1976
It’s not like Reilly is currently adding anything of value to Leafs defense.
He is easily their worst defenseman this year and no one on the team is even close to his - 16
Even Benoit has been better than Reilly.
If Leafs could convince Vancouver to take Reilly as a piece in the trade for Miller it would be a huge win for Toronto!
30 Jan 2025 09:12:42
In fairness to Ckps…. I don’t think he is claiming to know who to get…. He’s saying the D is very thin already. Slumping or not they would need a plan to replace Reilly if they trade him. I agree that having all three of Benoit, Timmins and Myers playing would be scary. Three #7 D right there.
30 Jan 2025 09:32:04
I’m totally in favour of moving Reilly if you can. Don’t think he fits in Berube’s system. But the D is very thin already and he needs to be replaced. Never once claimed to know by who lol. Top 4 D aren’t gonna be cheap.
Funny to say how awful Reilly is but expect the Canucks to take him as the centrepiece of a trade for Miller.
30 Jan 2025 13:58:34
Laugh all you want CKPS. You just admitted I was right that you have no ideas on how to make happen what you claim must happen. And to add to that, somehow the jokes on me because you now admit it like that is some kind of gotcha moment. Ok. lol
If I was constantly claiming the Leafs need to get a 3C before they trade any player who can play centre as a response to every proposal that moves a Leaf centre without getting one back, I'd be pretty embarrassed if I had to admit I have no idea who they should get or how they could do it, I just think they need to and that's why I keep disagreeing with all these props.
So to put this into perspective - every proposal sucks that doesn't meet the criteria that you yourself admit you have no ideas on how to meet. And that makes sense to you. lol.
31 Jan 2025 00:39:18
And yes…. I don’t know who they should get. Never once did I claim to know. Neither do you or anyone else on this site. But they can’t move him and rely on what’s left .