Leafs trade rumours 5

30 Oct 2025 20:22:13
Robertson for Colangelo.
Robertson could use a change of scenery and Colangelo is being used on the 4th line in Anaheim and fits a Leaf style of play more. Big right shot winger who plays physical.

30 Oct 2025 22:08:08
Any right shot player would be welcome D.
Particularly one with size.
Berube doesn’t appear to believe in Robertson so send him to a team that will give him a chance to play.

31 Oct 2025 11:49:07
Another bottom six player, or below average top 6. Not what they need. Until Matthews gets a legit right winger, this team struggles around .500 hockey.

31 Oct 2025 15:06:42
Ckps - Do you think Robertson lands a top 6 winger for Matthews? I would hope you don't think that. Colangelo is cost controlled for years to come. He is an RW that has pretty much scored at every level. Getting a controlled asset that could be used for one that doesn't fit, would be a good move.

31 Oct 2025 16:04:42
Never suggested that at all. Robertson may not even get you a third round pick. You don’t need a goal scorer with Matthews. that's his job. You need someone to get him the puck in the right places. They shopped in the bargain annex for Maccelli and that’s not working. Domi sucks. They need top right winger to play with Matthews or Tavares and put Nylander wherever that new winger doesn’t go.

31 Oct 2025 20:23:12
I think Nylander is a great fit with Matthews, so they don't need necessarily a top line RW. Imo, We need a guy who can carry the puck and have possession as they enter the zone on that line. McMann and Nylander should be good line mates for Matthews. Maccelli/ Domi would be better with Roy and Joshua. Need some speed on that line or another heavy player, so Maccelli/ Domi or Colangelo. Cowan with JT and Knies. Jarnkrok, Laughton Colangelo/ Maccelli/ Domi, Lorentz and Blais make up the rest and slotted depending on where needed. Someone obviously needs to go when Laughton is ready.

29 Oct 2025 07:39:34
Tor: Robertson
Chi: korshinski

Both players could use a fresh start I think both team are ok with this deal

29 Oct 2025 22:40:33
Korchinski just turned 21 this summer. Can't imagine Robertson holds the same value.

30 Oct 2025 06:27:47
Chicago struggles to score goals up and down their lineup they have 2-3 young d prospects that they’ve chosen over him idk I think it’s closer than you think.

30 Oct 2025 13:03:13
Maybe Goat. But defenceman typically take longer to develop and have more value than a winger. Especially a former 7th overall pick with offensive upside. He put up a .5ppg in the A last year as a 20 year old and has started this season almost a point per game 7 games in while being a +6. Both the young guys they "chose" over Korchinski are also former 1st round picks with Levshunov a 2nd overall pick. Don't see how that means they will give Korchinski away for Robertson. If he was on the market, you don't think they could get a better offer than Robertson? I think they could, but maybe you're right.

28 Oct 2025 23:22:15
Toronto trades Robertson Jarnkroc and Marcelli

To
Nashville for Marchessault

Lines

McMann Matthews Marchessault
Knies Tavares Nylander
Joshua Roy Laughton
Lorentz Boyd Blais
Domi

Toronto trades Carlo , Kampf

To

San Jose Mario Ferrio and 7th

Toronto trades OEL

To

New York Rangers for Brandon Schneider

Reilly Ferrio
McCabe Tanev
Benoit Schneider
Myers

29 Oct 2025 07:36:56
Marchesaults contract sucks tho.

30 Oct 2025 21:23:26
Yaaaaaaa let’s all finally get on the trade Maccelli bang wagon.

30 Oct 2025 22:15:51
Trade a RHD Carlo for a LHD Ferraro?
Seriously.
Can’t see why Leaf’s would ever do that.
That move would leave the Leafs with one starting RHD, Tanev and 5 LHD, McCabe, Reilly, OEL, Benoit & Ferraro
Besides, Ferraro is not an upgrade over Carlo.

30 Oct 2025 22:19:18
Drury’s would lose his job if he traded the 24 year old, RHD, Schneider for the 34 year old, LHD, OEL.
Drury has made some bad deals in his short tenure as Rangers GM but that move would be his crowning jewel.

28 Oct 2025 22:34:00
Matthews is forgetting how to score even get a point, like wth is going on...hes got what 6/7 points..is matthews elite? Im not sure anymore..i use to think he could carry a team...i think its berubes system that's ruined his game...im thinking he might need to go...matthews, cowan danford and a first for mcdavid.

29 Oct 2025 12:26:18
He still has the size and talent to carry a team, he just doesn't seem to have the drive anymore.

28 Oct 2025 22:08:05
Hey, is Treliving out in L.A. watching the Jays!

Get your ass back to your office in Toronto and fix this team.

Stop thinking that your players are worth more than they are!

Toronto trades Robertson, Jarnkroc Villeneuve, Carlo, Cowan and 1st in 2028

To

New York Rangers for Alex Laferianne, Othman and Carson Soucy


Toronto trades Domi, OEL, 2nd
To
Seattle for Adam Larson

30 Oct 2025 22:28:30
Absolutely tragic idea.
Lafreniere has never come close to showing the value of being a 1st overall pick or even a top 10 pick.
Lafreniere is now in his 6th year in the league and has only broken the 20 goal mark once.
Othman was drafted 16th in the 2021 draft and is still playing in the AHL, unable to earn a position on a really bad Rangers team.
Soucy is a 31 year old, at best a 3rd pairing, LH defenseman, a position Leafs do not need filled.

31 Oct 2025 11:50:43
Agree with WB on all of it.

28 Oct 2025 01:55:43
If bruins keep losing, maybe leafs should go after sniper arvidsson, hes only signed i think for this year at 4 mill i do believe..i know we wouldnt get him for a 5th rd pick, but maybe a top prospect a pick and a take on player like kampf

28 Oct 2025 23:14:28
Did you follow what Arvidsson DIDN’T manage to do with the Oilers last year?
Arvidsson is the last guy Leafs want to trade for.
Unless, perhaps, Domi and Kampf are going the other way.

26 Oct 2025 18:14:20
Morgan Frost can play both wings as well as center, so I’d slot him on Auston’s line at RW. Once Nylander is healthy, he should go back next to Tavares. So in the trade, McMann, Robertson, and Dakota Mermis would be going the other way.

Toronto’s having a pretty typical slow start to the season, but I don’t really see Robertson staying with the Leafs — Sammy Blais could easily replace the kid. Domi’s basically untradeable right now, so we just have to hope he starts finding his teammates and that they figure out a line combination that works.

A few other guys have been underperforming too, so we’ll chalk it up to the usual early-season struggles. Maccelli would fit nicely on Tavares’ line at LW — looks like Matias is starting to find his touch again, and I think he could easily put up 50+ points if he stays healthy.

26 Oct 2025 19:02:44
No thanks . I’d rather keep McMann and his 1.35M cap hit. He should not be considered to be moved.

27 Oct 2025 01:10:39
McCann is a trade peice, a cap bit balance when you need to finish off that last million.

27 Oct 2025 20:11:10
I purposed something similar in the off season I think it was Robertson and a 2nd as Frost was kind of in limbo would have loved to see him in blue and White.

26 Oct 2025 02:59:04
Leafs
Kadri
Flames retain 40 percent

Flames
Danford
Robertson
Holinka
Domi

26 Oct 2025 15:23:02
Why keep trading the future for guys at the end of their careers.

26 Oct 2025 17:12:21
Why resign Tavares
Why sign McCabe to an extension
Why sign Tanev to that contract
Hmm I wonder why Goat2.0???

Other than Danford what future are you referring to?
Holinka is 3rd line probably 4th line
Robertson skates 5 miles to get 200 feet
Domi is a cap space throw in

Kadri is nasty
He will be ideal with Joshua and Roy on the wings.

27 Oct 2025 18:30:56
I agree with Goat on this one!
While I like Kadri just cannot support this much in return.
Domi and Robertson plus some pucks is all I would offer.
If not enough so be it.

24 Oct 2025 17:33:57
Now Woll is in IR? what is going on with him?

24 Oct 2025 22:28:11
Personal matter. He's on his way back. Hope he's back to form in no time.

24 Oct 2025 13:05:44
A couple of thoughts…
I believe Cowan would benefit from a good long stint in the AHL; bring him back later in the year.
If a trade for Robertson is in the cards why not put him on L2 to build his value.

24 Oct 2025 16:19:53
yes, let cowen get regular reps on the top line in the minors till january at the earliest.

24 Oct 2025 17:34:32
I'm good with Cowan being in the AHL as well. I would have started him in the NHL for experience, but sent him down.

24 Oct 2025 18:18:19
Cowan being sent down is all good. Although, I believe the Leafs geel his is an NHLer now, but taking their time with him while he adjusts to the NHL game.
The issue I see with elevating Robertson in the lineup is that it can drive down his value if he continues to not produce. He produces and all good. He doesn't and he will be worth pretty much nothing.

24 Oct 2025 22:05:40
Do you think it would go down further than Lukas Reichel getting CBH a 4th?

24 Oct 2025 22:29:22
I like that he's getting a solid feel for the NHL level of play. Let's take things slow so he doesn't come in and out of the line up like Robertson.

25 Oct 2025 03:34:44
Don't know if it drops any farther than a 4th, but right now its likely a 3rd or for a prospect of similar Caliber needing a change.

25 Oct 2025 13:45:15
Yes, it seems like a 3rd would be the best return we could get for Robertson (probably will be a 4th, same as Reichel if he doesn't start putting the puck in the net) .
I think Cowan can stay on the team if he's playing 3rd or 4th line, definitely not top 6 at this point. He looked okay last night with Roy and Joshua, I thought that line controlled the play pretty well and had some good ozone pressure.

24 Oct 2025 13:03:16
So the Avs are again rumoured to be trading Necas.

He’d be a great add to TML and Avs need NHL players NOW but have little room to manoeuver so I’d offer up Carlo, Jankrok and Kampf.

Cap works for both teams.

24 Oct 2025 13:38:16
Colorado laughs their ass off.

24 Oct 2025 16:20:50
try something more like cowen, robertson, 2nd and maybe hildeby.

24 Oct 2025 17:25:33
Then Necas stays for this season and goes to another team next year.
Avs get nothing.

24 Oct 2025 17:26:51
Ckps,
At least Hrenklin gave an alternative versus your standard silly response.

24 Oct 2025 17:35:02
@@Hrenklin that's to much.