Leafs Trade Rumors

30 May 2026 16:40:45
San Jose: 2nd Round pick, Mukhamadulin

Toronto: Reilly, Quillan

29 May 2026 17:41:32
Tor: Nylander, Carlo

Ana: McTavish, Sennecke, 1st, 2nd, Ethan Procyszyn.

29 May 2026 18:48:21
😂
Geez.

29 May 2026 19:40:04
They can keep McT

29 May 2026 21:56:08
If Anaheim would, yes from the Leafs.

29 May 2026 22:20:27
Let’s just go after AJ Greer.

29 May 2026 22:42:58
I agree, Randy Sears. That is a realistic and productive move.

29 May 2026 17:22:03
If the Leafs are looking to add a big, top 9 forward who will fight and take on heavyweights, I would think Jordan Greenway is available. Buffalo needs cap space, Greenway's minutes have diminished the past 2 seasons and he is on an expiring contract making $4M.

May not cost the Leafs more than a 3rd round pick if Buffalo wants to move his whole contract and don't want to take a contract back.

29 May 2026 20:16:39
That’s an expensive 4th line dude.

29 May 2026 22:01:11
He was a minimum 3rd liner until last season. Hence the diminished minutes I mentioned and them wanting to clear his contract.

29 May 2026 23:08:56
A Big dude that fights that is not that good of a fighter. At least get a guy that can win some. Espcially at that price point. Offer up a good trade for Olivier for a million less and you get a better point producer and a player that changes the course of a game when he fights because the other team shrinks 2 inches when he is on the ice.



A few years back when Green way was in the $2.5 range he might be a decent 4th liner but at $4 no way.

30 May 2026 01:04:04
Interesting, when I had a prop with Matthews going to Columbus and Olivier coming back, you said Olivier is pretty much untouchable, you felt. Now when I offer an alternative, you say go after Olivier.

Of course, I would rather Olivier. You don't get him for a 3rd. Never said Greenway is a good fighter, I said he will take on heavyweights. At least he will. What Leaf does now?

30 May 2026 02:18:01
Wow, tough crowd tonight RFL.
They don't know what they ate even typing.
Go prop.

30 May 2026 02:48:22
He is pretty much untouchable but if you are going after an enforcer that is going to get paid $4M make sure it’s one of the best. If I recall Olivier was really the only player that was any immediate value to us in that trade and would make sense if Matthews was here to play with him. Sorry can’t remember your guys in the trade.

What I know is Greenway is not worth $4 million. Olivier on Columbus is a major part of that team and affordable that’s why it would be hard to get him. But if you are trading a Matthews or Nylander to do it you need to be replacing some immediate offence as well in that trade.

30 May 2026 03:02:37
I know everyone hates Division trades and especially with Boston. They have a much more affordable guy who woukd fit the role and can play a good reliable game Mark Kastelic at $1.5.

They have Jeannot and Zadorov so he could be had. We need to tread lightly though as we always seem to get bit with Boston trades. Maybe we do a 3 way deal to avoid the jinx lol.

30 May 2026 04:13:45
Suffering. The whole point of pointing out Greenway, was he's a guy that you can acquire for very little. Yes, he is paid too much, that is why Buffalo would move him for very little. Thought it was explained at the start.

30 May 2026 09:35:43
@RLF I view Greenway as a Dakota Joshua look alike. I would rather see the Leafs target a two way player with speed.

30 May 2026 11:26:52
A. J. Greer is a good but not great fighter but he brings a grit with good hard hitting and can score a bit too. I would rather see Florida sign him to $2 million and then trade him to us for a 3rd or a 4th similar to the way the Marner deal went down.

He would take 10% of our current available cap and bring more to the table than Greenway at 20% of that available cap. My opinion only, of course. Some might share and others might not.

30 May 2026 12:17:25
We can bring up different guys and that's great for conversation. Who knows what Greer signs for. He had 17 goals last year. I would think he is hoping to get paid. I am not saying Greenway is ideal, just should be cheap to acquire if the Leafs are looking for such a player.

I am not even a big Greenway fan. Just pointing him out as a possibility.

30 May 2026 12:31:35
I guess my look at it is yes he is cheap to acquire but expensive to have.

30 May 2026 12:55:22
My earlier Greer comment was meant here, sorry.

30 May 2026 13:03:38
Suffering. That's fair and I don't disagree. There may be no alternatives though that come to Toronto. That includes any of the D UFA's.

29 May 2026 14:45:44
First post!
I'd like to see a second line C and a puck moving d somehow
Could this idea work.

Rielly and Robertson
For
McTavish

He's young and locked up for a few years. Plus he's not super loved in Anaheim right now.
Plus Robertson could sweeten it enough as a plucky young goal scorer.

As for the D.
I heard a few people talking about Buffalo wanting to get something else in nets.

How about

Stolartz and a second
For
Byram.

And then free agency I really want Laughton back. He was misused under the previous coach and I really think he could be huge with culture development.
I don't think this alone fixes anything. But with some other smart moves it could be a pretty good looking team again!

29 May 2026 15:51:27
If Anaheim needed LHD's, there could be something there to work with. Problem is, they don't and Rielly struggles on the right side. I do believe there could be something that revolves around Carlo and MacT. I have mentioned before Carlo, Stolarz for Mact T, Luneau and Husso. If the Leafs were willing to take on Husso, may be a deal Anaheim would look at as they have good LHD puck movers, which Luneau is, but from the right side.

A more stay at home vet RHD should appeal. Stolarz, when healthy, is an upgrade on Dostal and Husso. This also gives the Ducks more cap space for UFA D-men.
I don't see Buffalo giving up one of their young top 4 D for a goalie. But, maybe you're right.

29 May 2026 23:14:13
Stolarz and a 2nd for Byram? That is a new Walt Disney Fantasy movie.

30 May 2026 13:13:19
Personally I’m not opposed to Mason McTavish; I think everyone is too critical of his skill set.

Remember he is only 23yo.

He’s been criticized for lack of consistency which could be a function of youth and how he’s been handled by management.

I’d be okay with him as a 3C this year and waiting until next year to put Tavares at 3C.

29 May 2026 07:59:25
Leafs
McDavid
Oilers
1st overall
Cowan
Danford
Woll
Quillan

Trying not to include Knies…

San Jose
Rielly
Leafs
Sahlin

Ducks
Carlo
Leafs
Colangelo


Sign
Tuch 10 million per for 5
Andersson 7 million per for 5
Ferraro 4 million per for 5
Not sure on the term on each of these but 5 seemed like a nice number

Knies McDavid Nylander
Robertson Matthews Tuch
Joshua Tavares Colangelo
Lorentz Groiux Tverberg

OEL Andersson
McCabe Tanev
Ferraro Villeneuve

Stolarz
Hildeby


I’m a rebuild guy
This goes against my philosophy
So I tried giving the Dark Side a chance…
Cap works
Better win 2 Stanley Cups next two years!!!

29 May 2026 08:52:07
I don’t think you need to sell the farm to get McDavid. It would be something like 1st overall Cowan, probably another 1st and another prospect. McDavid doesn’t have any term so there’s risk for any team trading for him.

29 May 2026 09:31:25
Goat
Your suggested package is essentially the same as mine, maybe even more expensive.
😂😂😂

28 May 2026 21:46:56
Like to start off by saying congrats to the Marlies winning game 1 in Calder Cup finals. Crazy with the lack of draft picks we have had that we still have a solid AHL team. One thing Treliving did do was bulk up our AHL D men and they look pretty good.
AA has been playing all the games and he is getting peppered every night. Brings up the topic of do we now have to trade Hildeby and Stolarz? Go with AA and Woll next year? Not sure if they will do that if this is just a quick retool.

Just cause of Wolls prone to injury and AA hasn’t played many NHL games. What are your thoughts on who they keep and who they trade? They have to do something with Hildeby this coming season. Maybe a sign and trade?

28 May 2026 22:50:41
I’m not a Woll fan for many reasons. Stolaz, when healthy with that frame—if he did get hurt, I think the Leafs would’ve gone to the Cup Final instead of Florida. That kid is lights out for me. Keep AA and Hildeby; similar frame to Stolarz and trade both Woll and Stolarz.

Lo, if we could use either of them for Wallstedt and have Wallstedt, Hildeby and AA and the other—either Woll or Stolly—traded for whatever a good pick or Defensive prospect, I’d feel pretty good about contending.

28 May 2026 23:12:11
Hey Clarky. Yeah, they do have a bit of a issue there for sure. I would maybe still shop Stolarz as part of a package somewhere. We don't have to do anything with Hildeby contract wise as we still have him signed at a low number until end of 2028. However he still needs to clear waivers if sent to the minors.

I want to see A. A get games in at the NHL level too. So perhaps there may be a few times we actually will have to carry 3 goalies on the squad during the year. Not ideal but it would not hurt us Cap wise just on how many position players we would have to send up or down.

28 May 2026 23:53:39
C'mon LeafsGM, you can't say you are not a fan of Woll for many reasons and not give any of them? Indulge us.

29 May 2026 00:35:53
Ok, the bobble head. Now this is a bit technical but there are two parts to a save
1. The puck hitting you
2. Where it goes afterwards
If you watch Woll, he is really good at number one but horrible at number 2, and I’ve seen it time and time again. After he gets a piece of the puck, he has no idea where it’s going. That’s a huge problem.

Look at Montreal's series winner against Tampa for reference. Woll is awful at controlling what happens after it hits him, awful at tracking the puck behind the net. He does the bobble head. Go watch the goals he’s let in against Florida and against Ottawa, and watch him lose the puck, lose track of it, and that’s unheard of to do it that frequently.

29 May 2026 00:37:51
@LeafsGM I’m a fan of Stolarz too, love the size and everything but for me you can’t be 240lbs and be a goalie. It’s too hard on your hips, joints and groins. If he was willing to lose 40-50 lbs, I would keep, otherwise it’s gonna be another year of injuries.

@Suffering, that’s what I’m saying with Hildeby, he either has to be with the big team or send him to the minors, which he will definitely be claimed.

Either trade him, carry 3 goalies, or let him and either Stolarz or Woll run the season? But I think AA has surpassed Hildeby and don’t think it’s right or fair if Hildeby is on the big club and AA has to stay another year in the minors after carrying most of the load for the Marlies in the crucial games this year.

29 May 2026 00:46:52
I think you owe both Hildeby and AA to wait til training camp to decide that. I think the natural peaking order would be Hildeby as he’s played NHL games but clean slight coming in to training camp.

29 May 2026 02:54:18
I agree with you Clarky. Stolarz is a large man and doesn't have that same dexterity and agility so is prone to more injuries. I would be looking at trading him to a team that is familiar with him like Florida, or possibly Edmonton. Hildeby I think might be a good fit in Philly as I think he would be an upgrade on Ersson. I would then look at seeing if we could land Gustafsson from Minny as Wallstedt is their guy now.

Then we try and pry another good young goalie in a trade to boost our depth but give A. A the bulk of the work with the Marlies and don't hesitate to bring him up when needed. As good as he has been in the Playoffs another season of consistency with the Marlies would not be the worst thing in his development.

Sorry I was confused when you said with Hildeby about a sign a trade.